written on Nov 15, 2011 by loribyrdphillips
Over the past several weeks, a series of discussions have taken place on Twitter and the blogosphere that revolve around the challenges and opportunities that museums face in an age of participatory culture. Â While debates about the intersection of museum authority and public voice have gone on for some time, this recent flurry of dialogue among museum technology professionals was particularly deep â Â and deliberate in asking the tough questions. You can catch up on this discussion at Nina Simonâs Museum 2.0 blog , Rob Steinâs series on the Indianapolis Museum of Art blog (Parts I, II, and III), and the Twitter hashtags #museumchallenges and #sgsculture.
In my research, I have delved into issues of authority in museums and the ways that new voices can be engaged in the interpretation of culture. What Iâve concluded is that the web is continually moving towards transparency and openness in an inherently participatory environment; museums will need to embrace this openness and inclusivity if they wish to serve the needs and expectations of their communities. There is a sense that museums are slow to grasp this shift in expectations and instead hold fast to their mandate to be stewards of culture and, therefore, the authorities of it. This has caused me to wonder: is there a middle ground between authority and open, participatory culture?
When Nina Simon posited on her blog, âWhat are the most important problems in our field?â my response was, âHow do we combat the authoritative voice of museums, while still remaining respected stewards of our shared cultural heritage?â Â I was inspired by Ninaâs point in The Participatory Museum that museum professionals should facilitate the platforms for participation, and there is power in managing that platform. This was the first time it was clearly articulated to me that sharing authority doesnât mean losing all control.
I was further enlightened by Rob Steinâs differentiation between âauthoritarianâ and âauthoritativeâ approaches to participatory culture. In Part III of his series covering the Salzburg Global Seminar, Rob defines (below) âauthoritativeâ in a more positive light in contrast to being âauthoritarian.â
âAn authoritative approach demonstrates the expertise of the museumâs staff in a participatory context that recognizes the museumâs role in facilitating access to cultural objects and information.â
So then, what is the perfect mix of authority and openness? Â I think that before we can solve this problem, the museum community may need to adopt a new kind of authority â perhaps a model of âopen authority.â Wherever this path leads, Iâm excited to watch the discussion continue and I hope youâll join in.
Photo by Lori Byrd Phillips
This entry was posted on Tuesday, November 15th, 2011 at 4:31 pm. It is filed under ideas and tagged with authoritarian, authoritative, Indianapolis Museum of Arty Museum, IUPUI, Lori Byrd Phillips, Nina Simon, open content, Participator, Rob Stein. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
Lori Byrd Phillips is the Digital Marketing Content Coordinator and Wikipedian in Residence at The Children's Museum of Indianapolis. In 2012 she is also serving as the US Cultural Partnerships Coordinator for the Wikimedia Foundation. As a MIDEA/NMC Contributing Editor, she shares ideas and resources for social media and digital collaboration in museums.
Check out Lori's blog "Museums and Motherhood" at http://hstryqt.tumblr.com
Follow Lori on Twitter: @HstryQT
Nov 06, 2013
MIDEAâs Associate Director, Alex Freeman, has the scoop on the most innovative happenings in th… (more...)
Feb 06, 2014
MIDEAâs Director, Alex Freeman, has the scoop on the most innovative happenings in the museum w… (more...)
Mar 28, 2011
Arthouse at the Jones Centerâs 2011 minigrant project involves the continuation and completion … (more...)
May 10, 2010
The Tyler Museum of Art (TMA) chose for its 2008-2009 project an exploration of early Texas art, foc… (more...)
May 10, 2010
This project highlights Arthouseâs building design for the renovation of the Jones Center in do… (more...)
May 06, 2010
The Rubin Museum of Art (RMA) is a nonprofit cultural and educational institution dedicated to the a… (more...)
May 10, 2010
mindPOP is an exciting new initiative committed to expanding creative learning for kids and teens ac… (more...)
May 06, 2010
The Museum of Fine Arts, Houston is located in the heart of Texasâs largest city. The museum is… (more...)